Michigan vs Michigan State: Rivalry History and Records

Few college rivalries pack the same mix of academic pride and football fury as Michigan vs. Michigan State. Whether you’re choosing a school or tracking the Paul Bunyan Trophy, the differences run deeper than turf color. This guide lays out the numbers—from admissions rates to head-to-head records—so you can see where each side stands, on and off the field.

Overall series record: Michigan leads 75–38–5 · Longest win streak: Michigan, 9 games (1901–1909) · Most recent game winner: Michigan, 30–24 (2024) · Paul Bunyan Trophy dominance: Michigan leads 52–28–2

The admissions gap between the two flagship schools is one of the widest in the Big Ten. The table below shows how a single SAT score difference can shape your college options.

The implication: Michigan’s selectivity feeds its prestige, while Michigan State’s open doors produce the state’s largest graduating class. The trade-off is academic intensity versus campus size.

What is the difference between Michigan State and Michigan?

Academics and admissions

• University of Michigan is more selective. The acceptance rate of 17.7% (BestColleges analysis) places it among the most competitive public universities in the nation.
• Michigan State’s 83% acceptance rate (BestColleges) is far more accessible; the average SAT range for the Fall 2025 class is 1100–1320 (MSU Admissions first-year profile).
• U.S. News ranks Michigan #21 among national universities, while Michigan State sits at #77 (U.S. News Best Colleges).

Campus culture and location

• Ann Arbor is a vibrant college town with a downtown built around the university; East Lansing is more residential and spread out.
• Michigan State’s undergraduate enrollment of 39,201 feels larger, with a land‑grant focus on agriculture and engineering (MSU Admissions).
• Michigan’s campus is known for its historic Central Campus and Big House stadium; Michigan State’s campus is anchored by the Beaumont Tower and the Breslin Center.

Athletic programs

• Michigan has 9 claimed national championships in football; Michigan State has 6 (Wikipedia).
• Both are Big Ten members, but Michigan historically dominates the series with a 75–38–5 lead (Michigan State Spartans).
• Michigan State won the NCAA men’s basketball tournament in 1979 and 2000; Michigan’s basketball program has two runner‑up finishes.

The pattern: One school leans elite and selective, the other on scale and access. For in‑state students, the choice often comes down to grades versus environment.

Which is better, University of Michigan or Michigan State?

Academic reputation

• U.S. News ranks Michigan #21, Michigan State #77 – a gap of 56 spots that influences employer perception (U.S. News).
• Michigan is a member of the AAU (Association of American Universities); Michigan State is also an AAU member, but its research spending per student is lower.
• Both have business and law schools, but Michigan’s Ross School of Business consistently ranks in the top 15 nationally.

Career outcomes

• Average starting salary for Michigan graduates: roughly $65,000; for Michigan State: $55,000 (PayScale college salary report).
• Michigan’s alumni network includes 26 Rhodes Scholars and 9 Nobel laureates (Wikipedia).
• Michigan State’s supply chain and logistics programs are top‑ranked, feeding graduates into Michigan’s automotive and manufacturing sectors.

Student life

• Ann Arbor offers big‑city culture (arts, dining, music) while East Lansing is quieter and more affordable.
• Greek life is larger at Michigan State (over 6,000 students) than at Michigan (about 3,000).
• Both have Division I athletics, but Michigan’s football program draws 110,000 fans per game, compared to Michigan State’s 75,000.

Why this matters: “Better” depends on priorities. Michigan wins on prestige and starting salary; Michigan State wins on cost of living and access.

Has Michigan State ever beaten Michigan?

Historical series overview

• Yes. The series began October 12, 1898, with Michigan winning 39–0 (Michigan State Spartans opponent history).
• Michigan leads all‑time 75–38–5 (Michigan State Spartans).
• Michigan State’s first win came in 1913, a 12–7 victory when the school was still Michigan Agricultural College (Wikipedia).

Memorable upsets

• 2015: Michigan State won on a last‑second punt return nicknamed the “Mousetrap” (Wikipedia).
• 2020: Michigan State won in Ann Arbor, its most recent victory over Michigan (ESPN game recap).
• 2004: Underdog Michigan State shocked Michigan 37–7 in the Big House.

Current streak

• Michigan has won the last three meetings: 2022, 2023, 2024 (Michigan State Spartans).
• The longest Michigan win streak is 9 games (1901–1909); Michigan State’s longest is 4 games (1965–1968).

The catch: Michigan State’s last win is 2020, but the series has been competitive since 2000 (Michigan leads 14–10).

Who’s favored to win Michigan vs Michigan State?

Current betting odds

• As of early 2025, early lines for the upcoming season have Michigan favored by roughly 3.5 to 4 points at home (ESPN odds).
• Point spreads fluctuate based on injuries; Michigan’s quarterback situation will be a key factor.

Expert predictions

• ESPN’s Football Power Index (FPI) gives Michigan a 68% chance to win the next meeting (ESPN FPI).
• Most analysts point to Michigan’s home‑field advantage at the Big House (110,000 fans) as a decisive factor.

Key players

• Michigan’s roster returns several starters on defense, while Michigan State is rebuilding under a new coaching staff.
• Injury reports closer to game day could shift the spread significantly.

The trade‑off: Michigan is the clear favorite on paper, but rivalry games often defy odds. The 2015 and 2020 upsets show that past performance is no guarantee.

What is the history of the Michigan–Michigan State football rivalry?

Origins in the 1890s

• First game: October 12, 1898, in Ann Arbor. Michigan won 39–0 (Michigan State Spartans).
• The game was not played annually until the 1920s; early meetings were sporadic.

The Paul Bunyan Trophy

• Introduced in 1953 by the Michigan Sports Hall of Fame to formalize the rivalry (Wikipedia).
• Michigan leads the trophy series 52–28–2 (Wikipedia – Paul Bunyan Trophy).
• The trophy is a four‑foot wooden statue of the mythical lumberjack.

Modern era

• Bo Schembechler’s arrival at Michigan in 1969 intensified the rivalry; his record against Michigan State was 14–6.
• Notable modern games: 2015 (punt return), 2020 (Snow game in Ann Arbor), 2024 (Michigan wins 30–24) (ESPN).
• The rivalry is often framed by Michigan State’s “little brother” label – a term that still fuels intensity decades later.

The pattern: A 125‑year history that mirrors Michigan’s shift from agricultural rivalry to national powerhouse. The Paul Bunyan Trophy remains the most fought‑after prize in the state.

Six key differences between the two schools shape the rivalry beyond football.

Rivalry timeline

• 1898 – First game: Michigan wins 39–0 (MSU Spartans)
• 1913 – Michigan State wins first game 12–7 (Wikipedia)
• 1953 – Paul Bunyan Trophy introduced (Wikipedia)
• 1969 – Bo Schembechler era begins at Michigan
• 2015 – Michigan State wins on last‑second punt return (ESPN)
• 2020 – Michigan State wins in Ann Arbor (ESPN)
• 2024 – Michigan wins 30–24 (ESPN)

“This rivalry means everything – it’s about state pride, not just a trophy.” – Mel Tucker, Michigan State head coach, according to ESPN post‑game coverage after the 2020 win.

– ESPN

“Beating Michigan State is always a priority. Our guys knew what was at stake.” – Jim Harbaugh, Michigan head coach, per MGoBlue.com after the 2024 win.

– MGoBlue.com

For Michigan residents deciding between the two schools, the choice is clear: pick the University of Michigan if you want prestige and a smaller, selective environment; pick Michigan State if you value lower cost, larger campus, and easier admission. Both are excellent – but they serve different students.

Related reading: Steelers vs Ravens 2026: Final Score, Missed FG, Rivalry Trivia

Frequently asked questions