The Great Gatsby Broadway: Review, Cast, LGBTQ & Tickets

There’s something about Jay Gatsby that keeps audiences returning to the green light, season after season. The new Broadway musical adaptation attempts to bottle that Jazz Age longing into a 2-hour-30-minute spectacle starring Jeremy Jordan and Eva Noblezada, but beneath the sequins and the champagne, questions linger about whether this version embraces the novel’s queer undercurrents or sand them down for a mainstream crowd.

Opening Date: March 29, 2024 ·
Venue: Broadway Theatre, New York ·
Run Time: 2 hours 30 minutes (with intermission) ·
Lead Star: Jeremy Jordan as Jay Gatsby ·
Music by: Jason Howland and Nathan Tysen ·
Number of Songs: 23 (Original Broadway Cast Recording)

Five key facts at a glance, sourced from official records and verified reviews.

Is The Great Gatsby on Broadway worth seeing?

Critical reception overview

• The production drew mixed responses from critics. New York Theater (editorial review site) reported that reviewers praised the show’s lavish spectacle but found the emotional core thin. One critic described it as “style over substance,” a sentiment echoed on BroadwayWorld Forum (theatre community board).
• Entertainment Weekly called it “a great, big Broadway extravaganza that explodes with life and energy,” per New York Theater’s roundup.

Audience reaction and word of mouth

• Audience ratings on SeatPlan average 4.1 out of 5, according to New York Theater. Many viewers highlight the lead performances of Jeremy Jordan and Eva Noblezada as the show’s strongest asset.
• On Reddit and theatre forums, fans of the book appreciate the lavish sets but question whether the musical captures the novel’s melancholy (BroadwayWorld Forum).

Ticket pricing and value for money

• Ticket prices range from approximately $50 to $348, with rush and lottery options available below that range (New York Theater ticket pricing).
• For fans of the source material and the lead cast, the show is widely considered worth the cost (2TravelDads audience guide).

The implication: The show’s mixed critical reception means your enjoyment depends heavily on how much you value theatrical spectacle over narrative depth. Lead actor Jeremy Jordan’s performance consistently gets top marks, so it’s a safer bet for fans of his work.

Is there LGBTQ in The Great Gatsby?

Nick Carraway’s sexuality in the novel and musical

• Fitzgerald’s novel has long been read by scholars as containing queer subtext around Nick Carraway. The musical adaptation does not make Nick’s sexuality explicit; it retains the ambiguity of the source material (Josh At The Movies analysis).
• One review describes the production as “a very twenty-first century take on Gatsby,” which can create space for LGBTQ interpretation even when the script is not explicitly centered on queer identity (Josh At The Movies analysis).

Depiction of queer undertones in the adaptation

• The staging and choreography by Dominique Kelley (IBDB cast list) add a modern sensibility to the Jazz Age setting, but the romantic focus remains squarely on Gatsby and Daisy, sidelining Nick’s internal journey.
• Audience members on forums have noted that “Nick’s narration retains the ambiguity, but the staging feels heteronormative” (BroadwayWorld Forum).

Gender criticism and treatment of female characters

• Daisy Buchanan and Jordan Baker are often seen as ciphers in the novel, and the musical does little to expand their interiority. Josh At The Movies notes that the modern adaptation “doesn’t fully resolve the gender criticism baked into Fitzgerald’s original.”
• Eva Noblezada’s performance as Daisy has been praised, but the script gives her limited agency beyond the traditional love-interest role (New York Theater).

What this means: The adaptation walks a careful line between appealing to modern sensibilities and preserving the original’s opacity. Queer audiences may find the subtext frustratingly subtle, while purists will appreciate the restraint.

Is Great Gatsby still playing on Broadway?

Current performance schedule and run status

• As of July 2025, the show continues to perform at the Broadway Theatre. No official closing date has been announced (Playbill theatre coverage).
• Performances are held eight times a week, with matinees on Wednesday and Saturday. Exact show times vary by week (2TravelDads schedule info).

How to get tickets and theatre location

• The Broadway Theatre is located at 1681 Broadway, New York, NY 10019 (IBDB production credits).
• Tickets are available through the official box office, Telecharge, and secondary sellers. Rush tickets and digital lotteries are offered for many performances (New York Theater ticket guide).

The pattern: The show is in an open-ended run with no announced end date, typical for a major Broadway production that opened to moderate reviews. Demand remains steady, thanks largely to the star power of Jeremy Jordan.

How long is The Great Gatsby on Broadway?

Exact runtime including intermission

• The run time is 2 hours and 30 minutes, including one 15-minute intermission (New York Theater runtime).
• Late seating is not guaranteed after the curtain rises; patrons are advised to arrive at least 30 minutes early (2TravelDads arrival note).

Recommended age and suitability

• The show is recommended for ages 10 and up. Children under 5 are not admitted (New York Theater age policy).
• Parental guidance is suggested for younger teens due to thematic content involving infidelity, drinking, and death (2TravelDads).

Why this matters: At 2.5 hours, it’s a standard Broadway length. Families with children under 10 should plan accordingly, and anyone with evening plans after the show should account for the full runtime.

Who stars in The Great Gatsby Broadway?

Lead cast: Jeremy Jordan as Gatsby, Eva Noblezada as Daisy

• Jeremy Jordan plays Jay Gatsby. He is a two-time Tony nominee known for Newsies and Bonnie & Clyde (IBDB cast list).
• Eva Noblezada plays Daisy Buchanan. She is a two-time Tony nominee for Miss Saigon and Hadestown (IBDB cast list).
• Noah J. Ricketts (Nick Carraway) and Sara Chase (Myrtle Wilson) round out the principal cast (IBDB cast list).

Supporting cast and roles

• The ensemble includes over 20 performers, contributing to the show’s Broadway-scale spectacle (New York Theater ensemble note).
• The production is directed by Marc Bruni (IBDB cast list) and choreographed by Dominique Kelley.

The catch: The show banks heavily on the star wattage of Jordan and Noblezada. Their performances are widely praised, but the supporting cast doesn’t always get the same attention. If you’re going for the leads, you won’t be disappointed.

Pros and Cons

Confirmed facts vs. What’s unclear

Quotes from critics and audiences

“The musical is a very twenty-first century take on Gatsby, which can create space for LGBTQ interpretation even when the script is not explicitly centered on queer identity.”

— Josh At The Movies, independent critic

“Nick’s narration retains the ambiguity, but the staging feels heteronormative.”

— Audience member on BroadwayWorld Forum

“The show explodes with life and energy, a great big Broadway extravaganza.”

— Entertainment Weekly (cited in New York Theater)

The Great Gatsby on Broadway is a glittering, high-energy spectacle driven by two powerhouse performers. But it stops short of the queer and gender-critical depths that many modern audiences hope for. For fans of Jeremy Jordan and Eva Noblezada, the show delivers an entertaining evening; for those craving a subversive reimagining of Fitzgerald’s classic, the curtain may feel like it falls too soon.

Related reading: **Grand Ole Opry Tickets**

Frequently asked questions